Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Victorb's avatar

Part 2

Respect for the corpse is consistent with respect for the perpetrator of a crime. Each soul has value and we need to be careful to show respect to each individual whether by not overdoing punishment for a crime or by honoring the soul of an individual that might otherwise go unrecognized or under valued

Expand full comment
Marc Karell's avatar

I think we are saying the same thing, but with different emphases. It is the human condition to want to be perfect - to run something smoothly and perfectly to achieve goals (remove criminals from the streets and respect and reform them to be useful members of society). I guess where we part is my acceptance that no system is perfect and given 360,000 workers in US jails and prisons some will crack under the tension and make errors, even bad errors. Of course, such workers who make such errors should be punished (fired, jailed themselves). They and all of us are human. When meshiach comes, perhaps we will have perfection.

Expand full comment
4 more comments...

No posts